What To Do If You Accidentally Eat Meat As A Vegetarian

You’re halfway through a bite when it hits you: That wasn’t vegetarian. Oops.

Your heart sinks. Your stomach churns. And your brain starts spiraling into guilt, self-doubt, and maybe even the urge to quit this whole vegetarian thing altogether.

First of all, BREATHE. I’ve been there—so many of us have. Accidentally eating meat as a vegetarian is way more common than you might think, and it does not mean you’ve failed. In fact, it can be a turning point in your journey—if you let it be.

Let’s walk through what to do if you accidentally eat meat as a vegetarian, so you can move forward with confidence, clarity, and zero shame.

Don’t Panic—You’re Not a Bad Vegetarian

This is the first and most important thing: don’t freak out.

I know that anxious, gut-punch feeling when you realize something in your meal wasn’t vegetarian. Maybe it was hidden chicken broth in a soup. Perhaps a friend cooked something and forgot to mention the bacon. Or you just didn’t realize that gelatin was in those cute little gummies you grabbed at the store.

It happens.

Accidental meat consumption is something nearly every vegetarian goes through, especially in the beginning. It doesn’t undo all the meals you’ve mindfully chosen, all the animals you’ve spared, or the values that brought you here in the first place.

Being vegetarian isn’t about being perfect. It’s about being intentional. And part of any journey worth taking? Occasional detours. 😉

Beating Yourself Up Will Only Make It Harder to Stay on Track

Here’s something I’ve seen again and again: when someone slips up and then immediately starts tearing themselves apart for it, they’re way more likely to give up on the whole lifestyle. Why?

Because when you tell yourself things like “I suck at this,” or “I’ll never be able to do this right,” your brain believes you. And then it acts like it. Suddenly, that one slip-up becomes quitting because you’ve been subconsciously trying to prove yourself right with your story that: “I’m not really cut out for this.”

Let’s stop that story in its tracks.

This one experience doesn’t define you. It’s one frickin moment—not a measure of your dedication, your character, or your worth! Talk to yourself like you’d talk to your best friend. You’d say, “Hey, it’s okay. You’re still doing great. Let’s figure out what happened and keep going.”

That’s the energy we want to bring.

Reflect: What Happened, and What Can You Learn?

Now that the guilt’s out of the driver’s seat, let’s take a look at what actually happened. Not from a place of blame—but curiosity.

• Did the restaurant menu not mention the meat ingredient?
• Was it a mislabeled product?
• Were you in a social situation where you felt awkward asking questions?
• Did you just not know that a certain ingredient was animal-based?

Whatever the cause, this is a learning opportunity, not a failure. Every slip-up is a chance to build more awareness, confidence, and skill. Think of it like muscle memory—it gets easier every time.

Hidden Animal Products: Watch Out for These Sneaky Ingredients

Sometimes, it’s not a steak on your plate that trips you up—it’s the ingredients you didn’t know to watch for. When a vegetarian accidentally eats meat, it’s often in the form of these hidden animal-based products. Here are some common ones to keep an eye on:

Gelatin

• Found in: gummy candies, marshmallows, frosted Pop-Tarts, some yogurts, Jell-O, and even vitamin capsules.
• What it is: Collagen from boiled animal bones, skin, and connective tissue.

Parmesan Cheese

• What’s the deal?! Traditional parmesan is made with animal rennet, an enzyme from a calf’s stomach. Many hard cheeses fall into this category unless labeled vegetarian or made with microbial rennet.

Broths and Stocks

• Chicken, beef, or pork broth can sneak into soups, rice, sauces, or even veggie-labeled ramen.

Caesar Dressing & Worcestershire Sauce

• Anchovies are the culprit here. A lot of people don’t realize these dressings and sauces aren’t vegetarian.

Refried Beans

• Some are cooked with lard (pork fat), especially in restaurants.

The good news is: once you know to look for these things, you start spotting them more easily. You don’t have to be obsessive—just aware.

My Personal Take on Hidden Animal Products

Let me share something with you, because this might help you feel less stressed about some of those trickier ingredients.

A lot of these “hidden” non-vegetarian ingredients—like gelatin or chicken broth in a sauce—come from the leftover parts of animals that were already killed for other reasons. Nobody is raising animals just to make marshmallows or Worcestershire sauce.

Personally, I don’t make a huge deal out of it when I consume something that has one of these byproducts. To me, it’s actually more respectful to use those leftovers than to throw them away. It reduces waste. It doesn’t drive demand. And it aligns with my values of compassion and sustainability.

That said: you get to decide what feels right for you. Maybe you want to avoid those ingredients 100%. Maybe you’re okay with a little wiggle room. The most important thing is that your actions match your beliefs and comfort level—not someone else’s checklist.

What to Do Right After the Accident

Let’s say you just realized you ate meat. What now?

Pause and breathe. Don’t spiral. This is not a crisis.

Drink some water. Not because of toxins or anything dramatic—just to reset your body and mind.

Decide if you want to continue eating (if you’re mid-meal). If your whole meal contains meat, you’ve got to decide if it’s a time to say “f*ck it!” and keep eating, or stop completely.

Seriously, no pressure either way. If you want to stop, great. If you’re in a situation where stopping isn’t possible or comfortable, that’s okay too. One meal doesn’t cancel out your choices.

Make a mental note of what happened. This will help you remember what to look out for next time.

Get Back on the Horse—You’re Still a Vegetarian

The best response after a slip-up? JUST KEEP SWIMMING (AKA: keep going!)

You don’t need to “start over” or punish yourself. You didn’t “fail.” You’re still a vegetarian! This is just part of the journey.

Think about it this way: if someone training for a marathon twists their ankle one day, do they quit running forever? Um, no. They rest, learn, and lace up again when they’re ready. You can do the same.

Get back to your usual plant-based meals. Keep making the choices that align with your values. You have every meal for the rest of your life to make a difference. You’ve got this.

If It Starts Happening a Lot, It Might Be Time to Check In

A one-time accident? Totally normal.

But if you notice it’s happening more regularly—like once a week, or more—it might be time to pause and do a little self-reflection.

• Are you finding it hard to say no in social situations?
• Are you unsure about ingredient labels?
• Are you losing touch with the reason you started in the first place?

None of this means you’re not “good enough” to be vegetarian. It just means something might need adjusting.

Maybe you need some go-to snacks. Maybe you need to revisit your “why.” Or maybe you want to talk it out with a veg-friendly friend or community (like our Club Veg community you get with The Vegetarian Guide).

Being honest with yourself is part of being empowered.

You’re Doing Better Than You Think

If you’ve accidentally eaten meat as a vegetarian, you are not alone—and you are definitely still on the path.

What you’re doing isn’t easy, especially in a world where meat is everywhere and often hidden. But it’s meaningful. Every meatless meal matters. Every time you pause to make a conscious choice, it counts.

So don’t let one bite (or even several) convince you otherwise.

You care. That’s what brought you here. That’s what will keep you moving forward.

Keep going. I’m cheering for you.

XO – Bailee

If you want to save this post for later, pin it with one of the images below! 🙂